Community Nutrition Programs and Why They Don’t Work

-


Programs aimed at increasing food access for low-income families are becoming more prevalent in communities recognized as food deserts.  Public health advocates continue to seek programs aimed at thwarting food insecurity.  Unfortunately, many program have fallen short due to a variety of reasons.  Despite several studies provide evidence for the effectiveness of community kitchens, gardens, and subsidized food programs, a recent study investigating the use and success of such programs in Toronto indicated otherwise.

                Loopstra and Tarasuk (2013) assessed the frequency of use of collective kitchens, community gardens, and the Good Food Box program—a food box program aimed at providing fresh fruit and vegetables to low-income families noted for having high levels of food insecurity.  Researchers found that less than 5% of study participants reported benefiting from these community nutrition programs.

                Study participants reported several barriers to utilizing the community nutrition programs, resulting in the identification of two common themes—(1) programs were not accessible and (2) programs did not fit with needs, interest, and lives of the study participants.  Responses falling under the accessibility theme included lack of knowledge about how or where to participate, the program was not within the neighborhood, participants did not know what the program was, the program was filled to capacity, participants were not eligible for the program, and the cost of the program was prohibitive.  Barriers falling under the lack of fit theme included time, interest, need, and health.

                Overall, participants rejected food assistance programs, denying a need for such programs.  Participants refused programs due to lack of promotion and education, as well as the presence of personal and program constraints that hindered their accessibility.  Predictably, a lack of food need was never expressed as a reason for denying food assistance programs, rather a lack of desire to investigate further program options was common.  Unfortunately, despite best efforts to provide effective community nutrition programs, alternate methods may be necessary to truly meet the needs of low-income communities.

LH

Loopstra, R., & Tarasuk, V. (2013). Perspectives on Community Gardens, Community Kitchens and the Good Food Box Program in a Community-Based Sample of Low-Income Families. Canadian Journal Of Public Health, 104(1), e55-e59.

Comments

  1. ksu internsSeptember 5, 2017 at 7:45 PM

    Overall, I was shocked by the statistics provided in this article. I thought it was increasingly interesting that only 5% of study participants reported benefiting from community nutrition programs. When I think of community nutrition I think of the success I have seen firsthand at my WIC rotation. I frequently saw mother’s accepting nutritious food and education on healthy eating which they could pass on to their children. I am not shocked by the barriers that were commonly reported (inaccessible and programs not fitting needs) as to why participants found the programs to be not helpful. I think that this is an area that more registered dietitians are currently needed. With the research background RD’s can provide, programs can be redesigned to better meet the needs of the community. Also, RD’s can help highlight the importance of healthy nutrition/lifestyles among the community to help inspire the population to take advantage of the programs already offered.

    TR

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Do you struggle with pre and post exercise nutrition?

-
Image
What should i eat before and after a workout? First things first…carbohydrates, proteins and fats are important for the body before  and after exercise. Exercising muscle preferentially uses carbohydrates from stored glycogen, but fats are also an important fuel source for energy production during exercise. Fats and carbohydrates are the two major fuel sources during exercise. Fats must be translocated and broken down from their storage form before they are used. Typically there is enough carbohydrate stored as muscle glycogen for exercise but as muscle glycogen stores decline, the skeletal muscle will then use some amino acids (basic components of all protein). More specifically, the amino acid leucine is used for energy.              It is important to consume an adequate amount of carbohydrates exercise to delay fatigue and minimize gastrointestinal distress. It is also important to consume enough fluids to prev...
Read more

Child Malnutrition

-
New approach to childhood malnutrition may reduce relapses, deaths http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/02/150211124024.htm               Moderate acute malnutrition is experienced by 35 million children worldwide. A new study led by researchers from Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis has suggested that feeding children until they have met target measures of arm circumference and weight may be more important than a set 12 week feeding time. However, researchers have found that the current targets, set by the World Health Organization (WHO) may not be sufficient and raising these targets slightly could significantly reduce the risk of relapse in malnourished children; a condition that has a 37% relapse rate. The study took place in rural Malawi and was comprised of 2,349 moderately malnourished children aged 6 months to 5 years old. Children were evaluated 12 months after treatment; 1,967 rec...
Read more

Harvest of the Month

-
Image
Harvest of the Month  August – Corn Good source of  fiber Carbohydrate source for energy Antioxidants Contains vitamins and minerals ½ cup or 1 ear = 80 calories   http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=90 September – Watermelon High in vitamin A and vitamin C Antioxidants and anti-inflammatory support 1 cup cubed = 46 calories http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=31 October – Apples High in fiber Vitamin C Abundant amount of antioxidants 1 medium = 95 calories  http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=15 November – Squash and Pumpkin High in vitamin A, vitamin C, vitamin K, vitamin B2, B3 & B6 Many minerals  High in fiber Multiple antioxidant properties  1 cup = 76 calories  http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=63 Decembe...
Read more